Introduction: The Sacred Bond of Citizenship
In the foundational years of our Republic, American citizenship was understood as a sacred, singular bond—a covenant between an individual and the nation. However, in recent decades, this bond has been diluted by the rise of dual citizenship, a legal convenience that allows individuals to split their loyalties between the United States and foreign powers. With the introduction of the Exclusive Citizenship Act of 2025 by Senator Bernie Moreno, the conversation has finally returned to a fundamental truth: being an American is “all or nothing.” At Top Path to Liberty, we believe that to preserve the integrity of our national identity, we must restore the principle of undivided loyalty.
The Problem of Divided Loyalties
The primary concern for conservatives is the inherent conflict of interest that dual citizenship creates. How can a citizen truly be devoted to the interests of the United States if they hold legal obligations, such as taxes or military service, to another nation? This “dual allegiance” effectively creates a class of “global citizens” who can enjoy the benefits of American liberty while maintaining a safety net elsewhere. In times of international tension or conflict, these divided loyalties can pose significant risks to national security. A nation cannot stand if its citizens are constantly looking over their shoulders at another homeland; true unity requires a singular commitment to the American experiment.
Civic Nation vs. Ethnic Enclaves
America is a civic nation, built not on shared ethnicity, but on shared political values—liberty, individual rights, and the rule of law. Dual citizenship, however, often reinforces ethnic nationalism over our shared civic identity. It suggests that one can be an “American” while remaining legally and politically tied to the old world. This prevents the full integration and assimilation that has historically made the United States a melting pot of strength. By requiring a formal renunciation of foreign ties, as the Moreno bill proposes, we ensure that every new citizen is fully invested in the future of this country, fostering a more cohesive and resilient society.
Restoring the Honor of the Oath
The Oath of Allegiance is not a mere formality; it is a solemn promise to “absolutely and entirely renounce and abjure all allegiance and fidelity to any foreign prince, potentate, state, or sovereignty.” Currently, our legal system fails to enforce the weight of these words. The proposed Exclusive Citizenship Act seeks to align our laws with the spirit of this oath. If an individual finds American citizenship so valuable as to seek it, they should find it valuable enough to hold exclusively. Ending dual citizenship is a necessary step in restoring the honor and prestige associated with being a citizen of the greatest nation on earth.
Conclusion: A Choice for the Future
The tension surrounding this bill is a reflection of the larger struggle for America’s soul. While critics claim this is a radical shift, it is actually a return to the common-sense principles of our Founders. The path to liberty is not paved with half-hearted commitments or divided hearts. It requires a people who are willing to say, without reservation, “I am an American.” By supporting the end of dual citizenship, we are not just changing a legal status; we are reaffirming our belief that the United States is a nation worth choosing—entirely and exclusively. It is time to make the choice: one nation, under God, with one undivided allegiance.
🔗 Essential Reference Links
- Senator Bernie Moreno’s Official Press Release: New Moreno Bill to Outlaw Dual Citizenship
- Center for Immigration Studies (CIS): Dual Allegiance and the Politics of Immigration
- National Review: The Case for Single Allegiance